top of page

Fiberglass vs. Concrete Pool: Which Is Better for a Pittsburgh Backyard?

Writer: BRK Custom Concrete
BRK Custom Concrete
28 minutes ago
6 min read

Fiberglass is the better fit when one of the makers' stock models suits your yard, and concrete is the better fit when you want a custom shape built on site. The fiberglass evaluation reports from Latham, Thursday Pools and River Pools list no model wider than 16 feet, while the American Shotcrete Association says "Shotcrete is very versatile and can be shaped to replicate natural rock ledges or boulders." On timing, Latham says a fiberglass pool can be ready "within two to three days after delivery."

 

The listed fiberglass widths sit beside a Pennsylvania road rule. Latham's ICC-ES report ESR-2014 and the Thursday and River Pools report PMG-1620 list widths up to 16 feet, and San Juan's IAPMO report ER-298 lists a largest width of 16 feet 2 inches. Pennsylvania's vehicle code, 75 Pa.C.S. 4921(a) (last amended November 2022), says "The total outside width of a vehicle, including any load, shall not exceed eight feet six inches." A 16-foot width is nearly double that (16 feet against 8 feet 6 inches), and PennDOT's permit rule at 67 Pa. Code 179.10 adds a pilot car once a load passes 13 feet wide. This guide compares size, install time, warranties, winter care and fit for a Pittsburgh lot.


Custom concrete patio installation process in Pittsburgh backyard with professional equipment and reinforcement placement

What Is the Difference Between a Fiberglass and a Concrete Pool?

 

The main difference is how the shell takes shape. A fiberglass pool is a shell built to one of a maker's listed models, and Latham's ESR-2014 lists each model by length, width, maximum depth and gallons. A concrete pool is built in place, and the American Shotcrete Association explains that "Shotcrete is a method of placing concrete and the characteristics of shotcrete are those of cast concrete." Gunite is the dry-mix form, which ASA describes as "generally a very paste-rich mixture."

 

That gives each type its strength:

 

  • Fiberglass: a known size, shape, and depth before the dig. One row in Latham's table, for example, reads 40 feet long, 16 feet wide, 8 feet maximum depth and 21,000 gallons.

  • Concrete: a shape set by the design, including replicas of natural rock ledges or boulders, per ASA.

 

ASA's Pool and Recreational Shotcrete Committee also maintains a strength floor: a minimum compressive strength of 4000 psi at 28 days for pool shotcrete. BRK's post comparing pool deck materials and their pros and cons covers the surface that goes around either type.

 

How Big Can a Fiberglass Pool Be?

 

Here is how the largest listed sizes compare in each maker's documents:

 

  • Latham (ESR-2014, effective November 2025): up to 16 feet wide, with 16 pool series at that width; the longest listed series is 44 feet.

  • Thursday Pools and River Pools (PMG-1620, effective October 2025): up to 16 feet wide and 40 feet long.

  • San Juan (ER-298, revised October 13, 2025): a largest length of 45 feet and a largest width of 16 feet 2 inches.

  • Leisure Pools: a longest listed size of 40 feet; the Ultimate model is 40 feet by 15 feet 5 inches, from 4 feet 3 inches to 7 feet deep.

 

Those widths compare with Pennsylvania's 8 foot 6 inch vehicle width limit, which counts any load. For permitted oversize moves, 67 Pa. Code 179.10 (as published through June 2025) adds a pilot car above 13 feet wide and bars moves from sunset to sunrise, on Saturday after 12 noon and on Sunday. PennDOT issues oversize permits through its APRAS system.

 

For a Pittsburgh lot, the practical question is whether one of those listed sizes fits the space you have.

 

How Long Does Each Type Take to Install?

 

Two fiberglass makers describe installs measured in days. Latham says "you can luxuriate in your brand-new pool within two to three days after delivery." Leisure Pools says "Fiberglass installation is a coordinated process that can move from layout to swimming in a matter of days."

 

A shotcrete pool takes shape on the site. ASA says "Shotcrete can be applied in multiple layers, sections, or phases without producing a single cold joint," and that a shell built that way should "be essentially watertight prior to final surface applications (paint or plaster)."

 

Either type also needs a permit check. Pennsylvania's permit exemption at 34 Pa. Code 403.62(c)(5) covers only "Prefabricated swimming pools that are less than 24 inches deep," so ask your municipal code office what an in-ground pool needs. If you plan a concrete deck around the pool, BRK's post on pool deck installation in Pittsburgh from start to finish walks through that phase.

 

What Do Fiberglass Pool Warranties Cover, and What Voids Them?

 

Each maker words its warranty differently, and all three documents below limit coverage when the water drops below the skimmer.

 

Maker and document

Structural

Surface

Water level rule

Transfer

Latham, Limited Lifetime Warranty (rev. April 2026)

Leaking due to structural failure, for as long as the original buyer owns the pool

Osmotic blistering, same term

Whole warranty voided by failure to keep water above the skimmer outlet

Original purchaser only

Leisure Pools, Product Handbook (May 2023)

Lifetime of the retail purchaser, not less than 35 years

10 years against excessive pigmentation change

Excludes emptying below the skimmer box, or by more than 30 percent of capacity, without prior written consent

Within 5 years of the original purchase

River Pools, warranty document (undated)

Lifetime structural

15 years against osmotic blistering

Void if the pool water is ever allowed to go below the skimmer

One-time transfer with documentation, procedures and a fee

 

The fine print matters. Latham's surface coverage leaves out fading, staining, and cracks, including hairline cracks. River Pools' warranty is void if the install skips the maker's instructions, "including proper backfill material and well pit." Leisure asks for registration within six months of delivery. Read the current document for the model you choose before you sign.

 

How Does Each Type Handle Pittsburgh Freeze-Thaw Winters?

 

An analysis of NOAA daily records for 1991 to 2020 counts about 82 days a year at Pittsburgh International Airport when the low drops to 32 degrees or colder and the high climbs back above freezing, more than Minneapolis (about 75) or Philadelphia (about 64).

 

For concrete, ASA says air entrainment can "significantly increase the resistance to freezing-and-thawing exposure."

 

For Latham's fiberglass shells, the water level is the winter rule. Latham's ESR-2014 says, "The pool and spa shells are designed to remain full of water at all times," so under that report, the shell stays full through winter. Latham's warranty is also voided by "Allowing groundwater to accumulate under and/or around the pool," and excludes damage from "the rising of the groundwater table above the Pool water level." Leisure's handbook says to follow your local Leisure dealer's winterization recommendations.

 

For the concrete around the pool, see BRK's post on how long a concrete pool deck lasts in Western Pennsylvania.

 

Which One Fits a Pittsburgh Backyard?

 

Start with the shape and size you want. If a listed fiberglass model fits the yard, fiberglass offers a known shell and an install Latham counts in days after delivery. If the plan calls for a custom outline, rock features or a width beyond the listed models, shotcrete is the method that can be shaped on site.

 

The upkeep comparison here comes from a fiberglass maker. Leisure Pools, which makes fiberglass pools, says a concrete pool will need "to have it resurfaced about every 10 years" and that "Fiberglass pools are built to last. They can last 30 years or more." Weigh that as a maker's claim.

 

As of October 2026, both types fall under the 2021 International Swimming Pool and Spa Code, which Pennsylvania adopted through 34 Pa. Code 403.21(a)(14) effective January 1, 2026. Section 305.2 says outdoor pools "shall be surrounded by a barrier," Section 305.2.1 sets its top at least 48 inches above grade, and Section 305.1 waives the barrier sections for a pool with a powered safety cover that complies with ASTM F1346. Local ordinances can add rules, so check with your municipal code office. For the deck surface, BRK's post on concrete or pavers for a pool deck compares the two.

 

FAQ

 

What is the widest fiberglass pool?

 

Of the evaluation reports cited here, San Juan's ER-298 lists the largest width, 16 feet 2 inches. Latham, Thursday Pools and River Pools list widths up to 16 feet in their evaluation reports.

 

What is the longest fiberglass pool?

 

San Juan's report lists a largest length of 45 feet, and Latham's longest listed model is 44 feet.

 

Can you drain a fiberglass pool for winter?

 

Not under Latham's documents. ESR-2014 says the shells are designed to stay full at all times, and Latham's warranty is voided if the water is not kept above the skimmer outlet. Leisure says to follow your local dealer's winterization advice.

 

How often does a concrete pool need resurfacing?

 

Leisure Pools, a fiberglass maker, puts it at about every 10 years.

 

Is a fiberglass pool warranty transferable?

 

It depends on the maker. Latham's 2026 warranty covers only the original purchaser, River Pools allows one transfer with documentation and a fee, and Leisure's 2023 handbook allows a transfer within five years of the original purchase.

 

How strong should concrete be for a pool?

 

The American Shotcrete Association holds to a minimum of 4000 psi compressive strength at 28 days for pool shotcrete.

 

Fiberglass Pool Installation With BRK Custom Concrete

 

BRK Custom Concrete, founded in 2015 by Robert Kaczorowski, offers fiberglass pool installation in the Pittsburgh area. The company also offers broom finish concrete, which its site calls ideal for outdoor applications such as driveways, walkways and pool decks.

 

Visit BRK Custom Concrete or call (412) 419-8123 today. Contact us for more information.


BRK Concrete

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page